
George Washington’s Sacred Fire
by Peter A. Lillback with Jerry Newcombe
(Providence Forum Press, 2006)
n the early 1990s I noted in a book review that there seemed to be a lamentable lack of recent biographies of George Washington and books on the War for Independence. In the years since then, there has been a noticeable increase in scholarship regarding the founding of our country. General Washington has been so well researched, and the publishing of biographies and other monographs have been so plenteous that even the lives of individual servants of Mt. Vernon’s history are book-length subjects du jour. Washington, A Life by the great biographer Ron Chernow won a Pulitzer Prize in 2010 and will likely remain the best narrative biography of the First President for generations.
Historians have so minutely dissected Washington’s life that controversies and disagreements have resulted in logical fallacies and misunderstandings of his life, especially regarding his religious faith. Thankfully, there is a book on George Washington that addresses most of the controversial topics of his life, including whether he was a Deist or a Christian, his membership in the Masonic Lodge, beliefs concerning Providence, failure to take the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper, views toward other religions, prayer, and other such issues. This 1,100-page book entitled George Washington’s Sacred Fire, by Christian historians Dr. Peter Lillback and Dr. Jerry Newcombe of the Providence Forum, includes a brief biography of Washington’s life, but its strength lies in the topical chapters that explicate the above issues. You can pick and choose the subjects of his life that most interest you without having to read the whole tome.
For Christians, the two most controversial questions have been the reality of the Christian Faith in Washington’s life and his membership in the Masonic Lodge. Both issues are dealt with from a profound and insightful theological framework, using the exact words of Washington in letters he wrote (estimated at between 18,000 and 20,000 in his lifetime), official pronouncements as a general and as president, and the testimony of friends, colleagues, and family. His own words put the charges of Deism to rest that some historians claim, seeking to make him a devotee of the English Enlightenment and ignoring the Scriptures. Washington was a very private person with few intimate friends, but contemporaries noticed his quiet and personal piety, iron self-discipline, and ability to correct errors of judgement or character.
Some Christians are alarmed at the influence that the Masonic Order seemed to secretly exert in colonial America, especially around the time of the War for Independence and the formation of the Republic. Lillback argues that the Lodge of the 18th Century before the French Revolution was very different from its developed and more revolutionary state in the following century and today. The historians of the Lodge want to claim Washington as their special icon of history, and some Christian historians are quick to agree with them. What the books of the Masonic order claim disagree with Lillback and Newcomb’s conclusions, and thus continue to hold to a conspiratorial view of the entire history of Freemasonry. Perhaps a definitive conclusion is not possible, given the strength of traditional arguments against the Lodge.
If you are building a usable library of American history, you must get George Washington right, and I strongly recommend both Lillback and Newcomb’s and Ron Chernow’s works. Mt. Vernon has carried both books for years, along with many others on the War for Independence and related topics. Add these to your shelf.